Effects of Online Versus In-Person Mindfulness-Based Stress Reduction (MBSR): The Impact of Adding Brief Individual Interviews

要旨

The COVID-19 pandemic necessitated the transition of Mindfulness-Based Stress Reduction (MBSR) from in-person to online delivery. However, the impact of this transition on participants’ characteristics, adherence, and outcomes in community-based MBSR programs has not been adequately examined. The present study retrospectively compared the effects on psychological well-being outcome measures of in-person delivery and online delivery without and with added individual interviews. A total of 506 Japanese participants completed validated questionnaires before and after participating in an 8-week community-based MBSR program delivered either in person (IP; n = 156) or online. Online participants attended the program either without brief individual interviews (OL-NoInt; n = 147) or in later cohorts with such interviews added to the protocol (OL-Int; n = 203). The questionnaires assessed three outcomes related to psychological well-being (PWB)—mood states, health-related quality of life, and perceived stress—and two presumed mediators of MBSR’s effects on PWB: mindfulness and self-compassion. Significant pre–post improvements were observed across all outcome measures in all three groups. Compared with IP, OL-NoInt demonstrated 32.3–62.0% smaller effect sizes in PWB outcomes despite comparable improvements in mediator variables. In contrast, OL-Int showed 27.0–184.2% larger effect sizes than OL-NoInt in both the mediators and the PWB outcomes, and was shown to be non-inferior to IP across all measures. Online MBSR may be as effective as in-person delivery when the program is augmented with brief individual interviews. Findings underscore the crucial role of instructor factors in facilitating effective MBSR online delivery. This study is not preregistered.

主題